As an experiment the two rows of yellow onions at the bottom of the allotment are planted according to each persons technique although I covered both rows. When I cover them it is just a sprinkling to help protect them from the birds. Not sure it really works but I've never not done it. It's supposed to be sand but I have soil to hand!
Top Row : R slightly pushed in and about 8" apart
Bottom Row : G gently placed and closer maybe 4" apart